Tuesday, June 28, 2016

Tripping in Tennessee, Missing in Mississippi ... Arkansas A-OK

Street Sculpture, Memphis TN
This past weekend I had the opportunity to visit two states I’ve never seen before. As it turned out, I also saw a third, by mistake.

This trip was occasioned when my husband (a musician and enthusiastic researcher) received an invitation by two libraries in the first two states to give talks about The Beatles last tour in the United States. As I am the resident techie, I  also get to go and this time, I had a good reason on my own account to research my novel in progress, Pavane for Miss Marcher.

Pavane takes place in New England, some years after the end of the American Civil War, or the War 
Courthouse, Oxford, MS
Between the States. When I first had the idea to write this story, I, like many Americans long generations distant from the conflict, had only the “accepted” history to go on, but I also had several personal experience facts from members of my family, friends and acquaintances that were and are in conflict with the “perceived history” taught in schools and universities now.

In fact, when I mentioned that I was writing a post-ACW novel, one colleague told me I “had better be on the right side of the story.” There is no more red flag to a writer than the injunction to tell “the right story”. Since there are always at least two sides, the declaration that there is a “right” side implies censorship.

Island Queen on Mississippi River
Solzhenitsyn certainly understood this two-sided wrangle between one side and the other, in his case the State and the Individual. When I was a student, the Individual was heroic and therefore, 
Solzhenitsyn was presented to students as a champion of the rights of the individual. In less than two generations, with a change in the political nature of the State, it is the Power of the State over the Freedom of the Individual which is favored.


Therefore, saying there is a right side of history must always depend on which side has the upper hand. The obligation of all writers is to make the greatest effort to present what is essentially “true,” regardless of being “right” as in “acceptable.” Conflict is the meat, bread and potatoes of the writer’s paintbox. History is at the mercy of the victors and those with the wherewithal to revise history to suit their agenda. 

I've now had the opportunity to experience Southern life in ten states and, without exception, I have fallen in love with the people, their civility, generosity, intelligence and kindness. 

5 comments:

  1. Love this, Leigh - for a couple of reasons. First, I agree wholeheartedly that there's always more than one side to any conflict. Second, I lived in the South for a number of years and love the people, the culture, etc. I get so sick of hearing people blame all the injustice on the world on the prejudices of Southerners. I can't tell you the number of arguments I've gotten into because of this.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Sandy. The saying 'the truth shall set you free' couldn't be more pertinent. But that only works if we're prepared to accept the truth and allow ourselves to be freed from our ideological chains.

      Delete
  2. Hi Leigh--
    How wonderful you've visited ten Southern States. I bet these details and experiences will enrich your new novel. I especially like your comment that "writers should make the greatest effort to present what is essentially “true,” regardless of being “right.” I like this because, as you say, being right is in the eye of the beholder. Whereas being true is more likely to stand the test of time.
    Victoria--

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I will do my best to incorporate what I know and have discovered in this book but I won't be writing the 'accepted' history, not after meeting so many Southerners of all races who refute what 'history' claims. Thank you, Victoria!

      Delete
    2. I will do my best to incorporate what I know and have discovered in this book but I won't be writing the 'accepted' history, not after meeting so many Southerners of all races who refute what 'history' claims. Thank you, Victoria!

      Delete